91É«Ç鯬

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


21 January 2026

Musings on our relationship with nature (1)

From James Hardy, Belfast, UK

Richard Smyth says the growing trend of seeing our relationship with nature as a spiritual thing is a mistake. But "existential" or "mysterious" are surely better words to describe it than "spiritual". Bertrand Russell, the great atheist philosopher, famously said: "We know very little, and yet it is astonishing that we know so much, and …

21 January 2026

Musings on our relationship with nature (2)

From Andrew Whiteley, Consett, County Durham, UK

Smyth is absolutely right that there are no lessons to be learned from nature. Morality and meaning cannot be obtained from nature or its study; their true source is elsewhere. It is hard not to feel that the deification of nature is a substitute for traditional religious belief. The fundamental question is: is nature – …

21 January 2026

Here's a design for an improved solar panel

From Eric Kvaalen, Les Essarts-le-Roi, France

Paul Whiteley points out that 75 per cent of the sunlight hitting solar panels is lost as heat, but roof-top solar water heaters convert 95 per cent into hot water. So let's combine the two! Have a layer of water between the solar panel and a glass plate, as in a solar water heater. The …

21 January 2026

The odds of alien life are better than you think (1)

From Ernest Ager, Whaley Bridge, Derbyshire, UK

Bryn Glover gives a negative assessment of the likelihood of life elsewhere in the universe. This is based on a New Scientist article stating the odds of the formation of the last universal common ancestor from a soup of chemicals as "less than 1 in a billion" ( Letters, 3 January ). Of course, we …

21 January 2026

The odds of alien life are better than you think (2)

From Andrew Shead, Tulsa, Oklahoma, US

Decades ago, New Scientist ran a feature about Rupert Sheldrake's hypothesis of morphic resonance, which posits that once something comes into being, recurrence becomes easier. He used crystallisation as an example: once accomplished, it becomes subsequently easier to do. We are in the universe; the universe is in us. All is one. As far as …

21 January 2026

Trying to solve the meteorite mystery (1)

From Bill Courtney, Altrincham, Cheshire, UK

After reading Alex Wilkins's article on the mystery of the missing meteorite, I asked Google's AI assistant whether you can make a pigment for painting rocks using iron meteorites, and whether iron objects look shinier in low morning or midday light. Its answer to both questions was yes. If accurate, this may indicate that Gaston …

21 January 2026

A reminder of the importance of rocks

From Susan Stocklmayer, Perth, Western Australia

In the article "Rapa Nui statues may have been built by small groups", the important materials utilised for the construction of these numerous and impressive stone statues are referred to only as having originated from "one quarry supplying the rock" ( 6 December 2025, p 17 ). Perhaps this is of no concern to most …

21 January 2026

For the record

The record X-ray pulse produced by LCLS-II in 2024 carried a terawatt of power ( 10 January, p 15 ).

28 January 2026

The struggles of comparing cars

From Guy Cox, Sydney, Australia

Ian Smith criticises my comparison of modern SUVs with older small cars. But I didn't make that comparison. Rather, it was made by Anthony Laverty in his opinion piece. I simply pointed out that, counterintuitively, the switch in public preference had probably led to a substantial reduction in fossil-fuel consumption. In my personal experience, that …

28 January 2026

Why we can't escape the simulation

From Bernard Peek, Wigan, Greater Manchester, UK

Some letter writers seem to have missed some of the implications of living in a simulation. It is provably impossible to detect that we are in a simulation. Should anyone discover a "fact" that reveals the simulation, the system admin can stop the run, edit out the rogue fact and restart from a backup ( …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop