91É«Ç鯬

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


9 August 2023

AI's advances really aren't quite as great as we think (1)

From Eric Kvaalen, Les Essarts-le-Roi, France

The article on using artificial intelligence to tackle scientific challenges paints too rosy a picture of its accomplishments up to now. AlphaFold sometimes inaccurately predicts protein folding. The matrix multiplication methods found by AI only achieve a 10 to 20 per cent improvement for certain small matrices and only when using certain hardware. The sorting …

9 August 2023

AI's advances really aren't quite as great as we think (2)

From Sam Edge, Ringwood, Hampshire, UK

I laughed when I read that AI could help create viable nuclear fusion power, with "energy so cheap that it could be given away for free". Nuclear fission was supposed to be "too cheap to meter" as well. In fact, it has always been the most expensive energy fed into the grid. The type of …

9 August 2023

Is this why psychedelic treatments are back?

From John Reynolds, Canonbie, Dumfriesshire, UK

While reading your article on the use of psilocybin to treat anorexia, and reflecting on the growing number of reports on similar studies of the beneficial effects of controlled substances, I wondered if we are seeing a "generation drug" effect? Are those who lived through the normalisation of the use of recreational drugs in the …

9 August 2023

All hail the new drugs for treatment of obesity

From Jon Arch, Welwyn Garden City, Hertfordshire, UK

I spent much of my career trying to discover drugs to treat obesity. The class of drug that my team and I found to work well in rodents was ineffective in people. However, others found them useful in the treatment of overactive bladder ( 15 July, p 32 ). How I wish that I had …

9 August 2023

For the record

Cosmic rays produce helium-3 and beryllium-10 in asteroids ( 22 July, p 16 ).

16 August 2023

The real cause of obesity has yet to be confronted

From Pauline Keyne, Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, UK

I doubt I am the only one alarmed by the idea of prescribing weight-loss drugs to children, as discussed by Clare Wilson. It comes amid studies showing that a rise in consumption of ultra-processed food is linked with a decline in physical and mental health ( 15 July, p 32 ). Manufacturers create ultra-processed foods …

16 August 2023

We can't just preach to rainforest nations

From David Myers, Commugny, Switzerland

Having visited Bolivia on several occasions, I found it spectacular. Moreover, as a scientist, I well understand the consequences of destroying its forests. However, I still have to question the nature of the commentary in your recent picture story on this. How can people living in higher-income countries suggest that Bolivians don't have the right …

16 August 2023

Your thoughts on how to think about new AIs (1)

From Eric Van, Watertown, Massachusetts, US

You write that "until we know what consciousness is, there is no solid way of testing for it" in an artificial intelligence. There is, in fact, a simple way of testing for it, provided the AI is incapable of lying about itself, has colour vision and hasn't been trained on the concept of "subjective experience" …

16 August 2023

Your thoughts on how to think about new AIs (2)

From John Andreae, Lower Hutt, New Zealand

You state: "Perhaps the relevant question isn't whether or not AIs can become conscious, but why we would want them to be conscious." If you see conscious awareness as the ability to express feelings, thoughts and intentions, then the importance of consciousness in robots that are to be useful assistants, carers or interesting companions is …

16 August 2023

Your thoughts on how to think about new AIs (3)

From Michael Harrington, Sydney, Australia

The consequence – or economic threat if you are personally affected – of AI is that armies of white-collar professionals, such as architects, lawyers and accountants, may become permanently redundant. You ask an AI: "Show me some designs for an east-facing beach house with a veranda and water views that backs onto a bush reserve." …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop