Letters archive
Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com
22 November 2023
From Emma Lamerton, St Austell, Cornwall, UK
After reading the discussion of the traditionally accepted 8 hours of sleep a night versus a possible 6.5 hours as optimal for maximum brain volume, I wonder if the difference may be linked to our measurements. Before we had smart devices with sleep trackers, we would generally assume that the time we went to bed …
22 November 2023
From David Baxter, Greenhithe, Kent, UK
When considering the origin of life on Earth, note that it all runs on the same power system of ion gradients across a membrane. As this is universal, it must date back to a universal common ancestor ( 4 November, p 36 ). How could such a system have developed on early Earth with only …
22 November 2023
From Sam Edge, Ringwood, Hampshire, UK
There was no mention of the admittedly unfashionable panspermia proposal, the idea that life came from beyond Earth. While it doesn't explain the origin of life, it could, if true, mean that the first organisms didn't come into being here, but in a different environment. In this hypothesis, life on Earth began not when the …
22 November 2023
From Keith Macpherson, Clevedon, Somerset, UK
Your article about chimpanzees seeking higher ground for tactical reasons reminds me of one of our cats. He would run upstairs for a better look if he saw something interesting in the back garden. What was curious was that not only did he have the nous to do this, he also had the orientation sense …
22 November 2023
From Kimon Roussopoulos, Cambridge, UK
John Kitchen pushes the idea that Victorian homes (broadly) aren't suitable for heat pumps, suggesting they may have to be bulldozed. Heat pumps simply output heat, and physically can heat any building, full stop. It is true that cost, unsightliness and regulations may be obstacles, but these are artificial constraints. Equally, all buildings are far …
22 November 2023
From Mark Wareing, Ashbourne, Derbyshire, UK
I appreciate the more realistic approach to so-called ultra-processed foods in your recent article, but would like to make a couple of comments ( 28 October, p 40 ). Emulsifiers aren't all potentially harmful "additives" as implied. Many occur naturally in food we eat, such as lecithin (E322), found in egg and soya beans, and …
29 November 2023
From Keith Kirby, Oxford, UK
You report that ancient Europe before any real human influence was full of savannah, grazed by elephants, along with a suggestion that if conservationists want to restore the ancient forest biome, we should recreate the processes that led to this landscape. However, is this Eemian interglacial landscape an appropriate or realistic biome model for conservation? …
29 November 2023
From Sam Edge, Ringwood, Hampshire, UK
In your review of Ben Goldfarb's book on wildlife-traffic conflicts, the figure of 2 billion new road vehicles by 2030 was depressing. Sadly, the mindset seems to be business as usual with the excuse that it will be "green". Everyone having their own car and the road capacity to use it is unsustainable, no matter …
29 November 2023
From William Hughes-Games, Waipara, New Zealand
The progress in South Australia on renewable energy is fantastic. But it would be useful to get away from lithium-based batteries for grid storage. This would decrease the demand and hence the price of this metal, reducing further the cost of electric cars to consumers ( 28 October, p 36 ).
29 November 2023
From Eric Kvaalen, Les Essarts-le-Roi, France
Graham Lawton writes that "coal ash alone contains an estimated 288,000 tonnes of lithium, enough to supply the US market for 130 years". But just switching UK cars to lithium batteries would require 50,000 tonnes of lithium, and switching the whole world would require 40 times as much ( 18 November, p 22 ).