91É«Ç鯬

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


6 December 2023

On the search for answers to the human condition (1)

From Joseph LeDoux, New York University, US

In her review, Susan Blackmore says she has learned much from my book, but complains there are already many similar accounts of ontological realms, and that I don't cite them. I do, in fact, cite the ones she mentions, as well as others, and explain why mine is different. My focus is less on cataloguing …

6 December 2023

Let's see the positive in weight-loss drugs

From Geoff Harding, Sydney, Australia

The weight-loss injection Wegovy, if it lives up to expectations and is used widely, can set the imagination racing on possible consequences. Improved health will surely increase average longevity, with implications for pensions and care of the elderly. Lower average passenger weight will result in lower fuel consumption and lower emissions for aircraft. If progress …

6 December 2023

Alien first contact is probably best avoided

From Maggie Cobbett, Ripon, North Yorkshire, UK

You say the search for alien life needs strong guidelines to be sure of what is really out there. Among those guidelines, I would include a caveat: be careful what you wish for. Although my strongest claim to scientific erudition is a barely scraped O level qualification in biology many years ago, I have always …

6 December 2023

Humans are well-equipped to deal with uncertainty

From Jonathan Wallace, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK

In her review of Naomi Alderman's The Future , Sally Adee makes the surprising comment that "we are uniquely ill-equipped by evolution to handle uncertainty". Surely the opposite is true. Our success as a species thus far is based on our enormous flexibility and adaptability that have allowed us to spread everywhere. Time will tell …

6 December 2023

For the record

In our look at links between Huntington's disease and IQ ( 25 November, p 10 ), a study in August focused on young adults who were alive, while research supporting toxicity of the Huntington's protein involved animal models and lab-grown neurons.

13 December 2023

Human innovation gives me cause for optimism

From Chris Uruski, Featherston, New Zealand

Reader Ian Elliott pessimistically suggests naming the first age of the Anthropocene Epoch "The End". Whatever happens to our species, the planet will still be here. It has been through worse climate fluctuations in the past ( Letters, 25 November ). In any event, human minds are generating ideas to ameliorate climate change if given …

13 December 2023

Our brains really aren't quite that superlative

From Tom Reimchen, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada

As a long-time subscriber and reader, I continue to disagree with the cliche that the human brain is "the most complicated structure in the known universe". What actually is the evidence for this? Some 50,000 years ago, when early modern humans were cowering in caves with the same essential anatomical brain and genome we have …

13 December 2023

Hope of finding treatment for Huntington's disease

From Carlos Estevez Fraga, Huntington's Disease Centre, UK

In a recent article on Huntington's disease, expectations for a successful disease-modifying therapy were set low. However, the presence of mutated huntingtin protein is clearly associated with the development of symptoms. It is therefore reasonable to think that lowering huntingtin can change the disease course ( 25 November, p 10 ). Three unsuccessful huntingtin-lowering trials …

13 December 2023

Why not try this way of finding alien life?

From Fred Richardson, Alice Springs, Northern Territory, Australia

When it comes to how to detect signs of life on other worlds, I think the assembly theory idea from Lee Cronin and Sara Walker needs expanding on. It relies, currently, on readings from mass spectroscopy, MRI and infrared interrogation of molecules to derive a complexity scale. In this system, molecules that score below 15 …

13 December 2023

There could be downsides to fattening up when old

From Barbara Wyvill, Kettlestone, Norfolk, UK

The idea that older people should be encouraged to fatten up a little is a pernicious one. Extra weight means extra effort in moving around and may discourage exercise; in addition, a poor diet is unhealthy in many ways, not just because it may cause weight gain ( 2 December, p 12 ).

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop