91ɫÇéƬ

Emotional highs and foiled takeovers

Pledges to protect the world’s fish stocks and halve the number of people without clean drinking water and toilets are at the heart of agreements reached at the World Summit this week. The strength of the agreements ultimately surprised pessimists, who had feared a backward step from the promises made at the Earth Summit a decade ago.

But there was a late disappointment when the summit failed to agree renewable energy targets.

The emotional high spot of the negotiations came in the early hours of Monday morning when, with green lobbyists camped out in the corridor, an impassioned speech from Ethiopian environment chief Ato Tewolde forced the deletion of text that would have required all international environmental agreements to be “consistent” with the rules of the World Trade Organization. “I’ve never seen so many environment ministers hugging one another,” said an observer.

The summit agreed to:

▪restore depleted fish stocks “where possible not later than 2015” and set up networks of marine protected areas

▪halve the number of people not connected to water supplies to 550 million by 2015

▪halve the number without proper sanitation to 1.2 billion by 2015

▪”substantially increase” the use of renewable energy

▪minimise health and environmental impacts of chemicals by 2020

▪”significantly reduce the current rate of loss” of species by 2010

▪tackle over-consumption in rich countries

▪”promote corporate responsibility and accountability”

Green activists saw the deletion of the WTO sentence and the addition during talks of a clause on corporate accountability as important victories. “Attempts by the WTO and industry to take over the summit have failed,” said Charles Secrett, director of Friends of the Earth in Britain.

And wildlife campaigners were gloomy that the texts on protecting biodiversity and outlawing harmful chemicals were watered down during negotiations. The promise to slow the loss of biodiversity is weaker than an agreement earlier this year at the Biodiversity Convention to “halt” extinctions. But not everyone was dismayed. As Clare Short, Britain’s aid minister, put it: “The environment movement always thinks about the stress we put on the planet…They always end up being anti-development without meaning to be. If we carry on like that, the world will split in two.”