91ɫƬ

Fire eaters

Did massive black holes guzzle the big bang fireball?

THE giant black holes at the centre of galaxies might have been born in the first split second of the Universe’s existence. So say a pair of astrophysicists who think the big bang fireball spawned mini black holes that quickly grew into monsters by feeding on “quintessence”, an energy field that might explain the accelerating expansion of the Universe.

Supermassive black holes many millions of times heavier than the Sun are found at the centre of most galaxies, but nobody is sure how they formed. It is widely accepted that these giants started to develop around the same time as galaxies, at least a billion years after the big bang. Each may have been born in one go, as an extremely large cloud of dust and gas in a newborn galaxy collapsed. Or they may have formed gradually as debris and black holes from stellar explosions settled into galactic centres (New Scientist, 30 June 2001, p 20).

But according to Rachel Bean of Imperial College in London, these processes would struggle to make the black holes so heavy. She and her colleague João Magueijo have come up with a radical alternative: the black holes grew into monsters in the first split second of the Universe’s existence.

Many theories predict the formation of baby black holes during this time. Patches of the big bang fireball would have been so dense that they collapsed to a point, generating black holes weighing anything from a fraction of a gram to a few million tonnes. But it was always assumed that these black holes would be too tiny to survive for long, and would evaporate due to a process called Hawking radiation.

But Bean says they might have grown fat on a diet of quintessence, a mysterious energy field that behaves like a kind of repulsive gravity. Some scientists think quintessence might explain why the expansion of the Universe is accelerating (New Scientist, 2 March, p 7).

According to Bean, a black hole would consume quintessence, absorbing the field’s energy and increasing its own mass in the process. “Black holes will eat up anything,” says Bean. “They would feed off the quintessence, just like they feed on stars and other matter, and then the quintessence couldn’t escape.” In a fraction of a second, quintessence would fatten the mini black holes up to several million solar masses.

Much later, the black holes would become shrouded in the raw materials for star formation. “It’s interesting to turn the arguments round and suggest black holes were there from the beginning, and they in turn were the seeds for galaxies,” says Bean. “Observations don’t rule that out.”

David Spergel of Princeton University in New Jersey thinks it deserves further study. “The primordial black hole idea is intriguing,” he says, adding that quintessence is a very plausible source of the Universe’s acceleration. However, he says, observations of galaxies that host monster black holes hint that a significant part of the holes’ masses came from ordinary matter raining onto them from outside.

  • More at:

More from New Scientist

Explore the latest news, articles and features