91ɫƬ

The truth about warp drive

If you're a fan of Star Trek you might want to look away now

IMPLAUSIBLY high energy demands and insurmountable engineering difficulties haven’t stopped people fantasising about “warp drives” that could propel spaceships across the Universe faster than the speed of light. But now a Portuguese mathematician says he has proved that the idea is impossible.

Although Albert Einstein’s special theory of relativity says nothing can travel faster than light, Mexican mathematician Miguel Alcubierre found a way round the problem in 1994. He showed that a bubble with walls made of negative energy would distort the space around it. In theory, if the bubble contracted the space immediately in front of it and expanded the space behind, it could travel faster even than light. No one knows if negative energy exists, but Einstein’s theory doesn’t rule it out.

Unfortunately, Jose Natario of the Higher Institute of Technology in Lisbon has spelled out some fatal problems with the idea of warp drive. He began by working out what an astronaut standing on the bridge of a starship would see as the bubble overtook the speed of light. He says light coming from in front would be shifted to bright blue, while nothing would be visible behind because light wouldn’t be able to keep up. The view to the side would look normal. “Unlike the films, you don’t see stripes or flashes,” he says.

The problem comes when you consider how observers in the bubble might send signals to the world outside. The astronauts would overtake any signals they sent forward, generating a barrier or “horizon” beyond which they could never communicate. Natario calculated that the horizon would actually cut the wall of the bubble in two (see Graphic). That means the travellers couldn’t send signals to control the part of the bubble wall in front of them, making it impossible to steer or stop. “They can’t even generate it [in the first place],” says Natario.

The truth about warp drive

Michael Pfenning, who works on warp drive problems at the University of York, suggests people outside the bubble might lend a hand by controlling the bubble walls. “This means someone has to travel to the other end at normal speeds first,” he says.

But even if that works, there’s another, even bigger problem. Any light or other radiation emitted by the travellers would build up at the horizon, unable to get past. Natario worked out that because the boundary is infinitely thin, the energy from that radiation would get squashed to an infinite density. Under such extreme conditions, physics as we know it would break down.

Pfenning says there’s a slim chance that light rays don’t really behave like the geometrical curves Natario considers. So he’s going to keep working on the problem. “It was always going to be an engineering nightmare,” he says. But even if warp drive can never break the light barrier, he says it might still be possible to use it to travel just below light speed – too slow to compete with Captain Kirk and his crew, but fast enough to reach neighbouring star systems in decades.

  • More at: Classical and Quantum Gravity ()
Topics: Space flight